How the watch knows you're climbing

Not from your heart rate. From air pressure, which changes by a measurable amount for every metre you climb.

By Ben Widdowson · · 7 minute read

The short answer. The Apple Watch has a barometer. Air pressure drops as you go up, so the watch can tell when you have left the mats and how high you got. Crux counts an attempt when you rise half a metre and stay there for a second, ends it when you come back down, and keeps the high point of every go. Movement data tells it whether you were walking up stairs or dropped off the wall.

Try it: hold to climb

The figures at a glance

0.5 mrise, held for a second, starts an attempt
1.5 sback down before an attempt is closed
1 m, 8 sor more and the attempt is counted without asking
160 msof near-weightlessness marks a fall or a jump

Why heart rate isn't enough

Most fitness tracking starts from heart rate. In climbing that tells you little about what happened. Your heart rate climbs while you grip and stays high while you rest, so a session looks like one long effort. It can't tell an attempt from the minute you spent chalking up and staring at the problem.

Climbing has a clearer signal: you go up. A typical bouldering attempt in competition lasts about half a minute, followed by around two minutes of rest.2 Every one of those attempts starts by leaving the ground.

Height from air pressure

The watch's barometer reports changes in height relative to where it started.1 It is too noisy to give your height above sea level, but it is good at changes of a metre or so over a few seconds, which is exactly what a boulder problem looks like.

1. Leave the groundYou rise more than half a metre above where you were standing, and stay there for a second.
2. ClimbThe watch keeps the highest point you reach on this go.
3. Come offYou come back down and stay down for a second and a half. The attempt closes.

The mats problem

The first version ended an attempt only when you got back to the height you started from. That works on a route. In a bouldering gym it doesn't: you start on the floor and land on mats 30 to 40 cm thick, so you never quite get back down, and the attempt never ended.

Now there are two ways an attempt ends: back where you started, or half a metre below this attempt's own high point. The second works whatever you land on. After each attempt the watch takes wherever you came to rest as the new starting height, so the mats never add up across a session.

Stairs and ramps

Walking upstairs also gains height. When a rise looks like an attempt, Crux checks the movement from the last few seconds. Walking has a steady rhythm of one to two steps a second; climbing doesn't. If the rhythm is there, the rise is ignored.

When it asks, and when it doesn't

A clear attempt, a metre or more and at least eight seconds on the wall, is counted straight away with a tap on the wrist and an Undo. A smaller rise could be a real attempt on a low start or just standing on a block, so the watch asks. You can tell it to count those too.

You can always add or take away an attempt by hand. Your count is the one that's kept.

Falls, and how high you got

When you drop off the wall, the watch is briefly close to weightless. Crux looks for eight readings in a row, about 160 milliseconds, below a third of normal gravity while you're on the wall. That marks the attempt as ending in a fall.

A jump down from the top of a boulder looks exactly the same, so Crux shows this as roughly how many falls there were and never decides whether you sent from it. You do that.

The high point of each attempt is kept. On a problem you're working, the marks bunch up below the move that keeps stopping you. On the watch, a bar fills as you climb, with a mark for each earlier attempt.

What else the watch records

  • Time on the wall and resting, per attempt and for the session. This is what makes Crux's calorie figure possible.
  • Heart rate peak for each attempt, taken from every reading during the attempt, not just at the start and end.
  • Height climbed in the session, adding every attempt, including the ones you fell off.
  • A guess at the terrain. How fast you gained height and how your arm moved suggest slab, vertical, overhang or traverse. It's a suggestion you confirm, and it learns from your answers.

What it gets wrong

  • Traverses. Moving sideways gains little height, so a long traverse can be missed or counted short.
  • Very low starts. A sit start that tops out under a metre is close to the noise.
  • Air pressure changes. Doors opening and air handling move the reading a little. Half a metre held for a second filters out most of it, but not all.
  • Sends. The watch can't see whether you topped out. You tell it.

These thresholds are starting points, set from our own sessions. We expect to tune them as more climbers use Crux.

Common questions

Does it work for sport climbing?

Yes. Routes are taller, so the rise is unmistakable. The watch counts the attempt and its high point the same way.

Do I need to press anything?

Pick Boulder, Sport or Board and climb. When you're done with a climb, tap Sent it or Give up. With Just climb you don't even do that: the watch records the whole visit and you sort the climbs out on your phone afterwards.

Does Crux use my location?

Only once, when you start a session, to suggest which gym you're at. Height comes from air pressure, not GPS.

Sources

  1. Apple Developer Documentation. CMAltimeter: relative altitude from the barometric pressure sensor. Link
  2. White DJ, Olsen PD. A time motion analysis of bouldering style competitive rock climbing. J Strength Cond Res 2010;24(5):1356–1360.

Found an error? Email hello@cruxlog.app. This note is general information, not medical or coaching advice for your situation.

See your own climbing this way

Crux is in beta on iPhone and Apple Watch.

Join the beta