How Beta works, and what it won't say

An AI coach is only as good as what it's allowed to say. Beta is given your logbook, the numbers worked out in advance, and a list of things it must never do.

By Ben Widdowson · · 6 minute read

The short answer. Beta is Anthropic's Claude, given a summary of your own logged sessions and a set of rules. Counts such as climbs, sends and flashes are worked out by Crux before Beta sees them, so Beta quotes them rather than counting. Recovery signals are only passed on when there's enough data, and otherwise Beta says nothing about them. It gives no medical advice and never suggests eating under 1,200 kcal a day.

Try it: add data

The figures at a glance

1,200kcal a day: Beta never suggests eating less
750kcal below your own goal: the deepest cut it will suggest
0name or email address sent with any request
0of your data used to train AI models

What Beta is given

Each feature sends only what it needs. A session review gets that session, your recent sessions of the same kind, your goals and, for climbing, the session's figures already worked out. Nutrition guidance gets your targets, what you've logged today and your recent training. Your name and email address are never included. Under Anthropic's terms for API customers, the data isn't used to train their models.

Counting happens before Beta

Language models are poor at counting rows. An early version of Beta read a session's climbs and called two V5s that took four and two goes "two flashes". So Crux now works out the figures first: climbs, sends, flashes, sends by grade with the goes each took, your hardest send and the grades above your usual level. Duplicate climbs from a watch retrying are removed first. Beta is told to quote these figures and never count for itself.

No data, no comment

Recovery signals are only passed to Beta when there is enough data behind them. If there isn't, the signal is left empty and Beta is told an empty signal means say nothing, not guess.

SignalNeeds at leastMentioned when
Training load5 sessions with an effort and a length, in the last 28 daysBuilding up, steady or easing off
Resting heart rate10 days of readings, plus one in the last 2 daysMore than 5% above your usual
SleepThe sameMore than 15% below your usual
Heart rate variabilityThe sameMore than 15% below your usual

Each signal stays separate. Crux doesn't blend them into one recovery score, because a single number would hide which one moved.

What Beta won't say

  • Very low calorie targets. Never under 1,200 kcal a day, and never more than about 750 kcal below your own goal. If the numbers seem to call for more, Beta says your goal may need reviewing instead.
  • Diagnoses. No named conditions. A higher resting heart rate is described as "a bit higher than usual lately", with a plain suggestion such as more rest or water, never more definite than that.
  • Food as morality. No "earn your food", no praise or blame for what you ate.
  • Research it wasn't given. Beta mustn't quote studies or statistics that aren't in the data it was sent.
  • Anything that contradicts a note you've made about an allergy, a medical condition or how you eat. Those are treated as fixed.

Showing its working

When you ask Beta a question, it answers from a summary of your last 90 days of climbing and 60 of other training, in at most 120 words, and lists up to three figures it used. Every number in the answer has to come from your logbook. If the logbook doesn't hold what the question needs, Beta says so and suggests what to log. Questions about pain, injury or losing weight quickly get pointed to a physiotherapist, doctor or dietitian.

What we do not claim

  • That Beta is never wrong. The rules make some mistakes less likely, not impossible. That's why every card has a thumbs up and down.
  • That it replaces a coach who watches you climb. Beta only knows what you log. It can't see your footwork.
  • That it gives medical advice. It doesn't, and it's told to say so.

The privacy policy describes what is sent in its section on Beta, the AI coach.

Common questions

Is Beta a person?

No. Beta is an AI model, Anthropic's Claude, given your logbook and a set of rules.

Can I change how Beta talks to me?

Yes. Settings has a coaching style: balanced, direct, encouraging or technical. It changes the tone, never the facts or the safety rules.

What if Beta gets something wrong?

Give the card a thumbs down and say what was off. Those notes are read and used to fix Beta.

Found an error? Email hello@cruxlog.app. This note is general information, not medical or coaching advice for your situation.

See your own climbing this way

Crux is in beta on iPhone and Apple Watch.

Join the beta